| 2024 | Tyler Casson | Williamsville | A Womens | Drew Sterkel | Tuscola |
| 2024 | Julian Murphy | Northridge Prep | A Mens | Joe & Janey Erb | Winnabago |
| 2024 | Matt Haffner | St. Ignatius | AA Womens | Randy Anderson | Normal University |
| 2024 | Dan Dziubski & Adam Palumbo | Walter Payton | AA Mens | Barry Malloyd | East St. Louis |
| 2024 | Debbie Revolta | Barrington | AAA Womens | Peter Wintermute | Prospect |
| 2024 | John Sipple | Downers Grove North | AAA Mens | Tim Hasso | Oak Park River Forest |
| 2023 | Kara Leaman | Tolono Unity | A Womens | Joe Erb | Winnebago |
| 2023 | Neal Garrison | Tuscola | A Mens | Ryan Hornaday | Tuscola |
| 2023 | Mike Garber | Chatham-Glenwood | AA Womens | Marques Lowe | Kankakee |
| 2023 | Scott Gill | Marion | AA Mens | Barry Malloyd | East St. Louis |
| 2023 | Lauren Deangelis | York | AAA Womens | Jason Monson | Huntley |
| 2023 | John Sipple | Downers Grove North | AAA Mens | Nate Beebe | Homewood Flossmoor |
| 2022 | Kara Leaman | Tolono Unity | A Womens | Drew Sterkel | Tuscola |
| 2022 | Dan Daly | Chicago Latin | A Mens | Philip Surprenant | Salt Fork |
| 2022 | James Centella | Grayslake Central | AA Womens | Marques Lowe | Kankakee |
| 2022 | John Brady | Riverside-Brookfield | AA Mens | Marques Lowe | Kankakee |
| 2022 | Peter Wintermute | Prospect | AAA Womens | Peter Wintermute | Prospect |
| 2022 | Jason Crowe | Plainfield South | AAA Mens | Joshua Sterling | Centennial |
| 2021 | Kara Leaman | Tolono Unity | A Womens | Joe Erb | Winnebago |
| 2021 | Dan Daly | Chicago Latin | A Mens | Jason Retz | St. Joseph Ogden |
| 2021 | James Centella | Grayslake Central | AA Womens | Dan Daly | Chicago Latin |
| 2021 | David Rill | Fenwick | AA Mens | Brett Charlton | Eureka |
| 2021 | Lauren DeAngelis | York | AAA Womens | Dan Iverson | Naperville North |
| 2021 | John O'Malley | Sandburg | AAA Mens | Nick Lundin | Minooka |
| 2019 | Joe and Janet Erb | Winnebago | A Womens | Dan Daly | Chicago Latin |
| 2019 | Steven Bland | Harvest Christian | A Mens | Robert White | Melrose Park Walther Christian |
| 2019 | Scott Brooks | Benet Academy | AA Womens | Kyle Morey | Geneseo |
| 2019 | Chad Clarey | Kaneland | AA Mens | Derek Augustnynowicz | Dolton Thornridge |
| 2019 | Dan Iverson | Naperville North | AAA Womens | Kelly Hass | Glenbard West |
| 2019 | Chris Bosworth | St. Charles East | AAA Mens | Brian O'Donnell | Crete-Monee |
| 2018 | Mark Truesdell | Rock Falls | A Womens | Dale Donner | Bureau Valley |
| 2018 | David Ladehoff | Clifton Central | A Mens | Randy Moore | Rockford Christian |
| 2018 | Ken Husser | Belvidere North | AA Womens | Homer Thomas | Chicago Brooks |
| 2018 | Chad Clarey | Kaneland | AA Mens | Dan Thorpe | Marmion Academy |
| 2018 | Dan Iverson | Naperville North | AAA Womens | Dan Iverson | Naperville North |
| 2018 | Chrisopher Kuntz | Wheaton Warrenville South | AAA Mens | Mike Kennedy | Neuqua Valley |
| 2015 | Creston Fern | Kewanee Weathersfield | A Womens | Anna McQuade | Aurora Christian |
| 2015 | Chris Setzler | Johnsburg | A Mens | Andy Accardi | Sterling Newman |
| 2015 | Chris Muth | Yorkville | AA Womens | Derrick Calhoun | Chicago Morgan Park |
| 2015 | James Centella | Grayslake Central | AA Mens | Mike Schmidt | Burlington Central |
| 2015 | Kevin Gummerson | Minooka | AAA Womens | Brian Evans | Lincoln Way East |
| 2015 | John O'Malley | Sandburg | AAA Mens | Don Michelin | Evanston |
| 2014 | Creston Fenn | Kewanee | A Womens | Anna McQuade | Aurora Christian |
| 2014 | Randy Moore | Rockford Christian | A Mens | Anna McQuade | Aurora Christian |
| 2014 | Chris Muth | Yorkville | AA Womens | Mark Tacchi | Glenbard South |
| 2014 | Chris Muth | Yorkville | AA Mens | Eric Baron | Kaneland |
| 2014 | Dan Iverson | Naperville North | AAA Womens | Wendy Hegarty | Lincolnway East |
| 2014 | Jim Westphal | Hinsdale Central | AAA Mens | Stan Reddel | York |
| 2013 | Dan Daly | Chicago Latin | A Womens | Anna Morgan | Aurora Christian |
| 2013 | Joe & Janet Erb | Winnebago | A Mens | Andy Accardi | Newman Central Catholic |
| 2013 | Chris Muth | Yorkville | AA Womens | Mark Tacchi | Glenbard South |
| 2013 | Chris Muth | Yorkville | AA Mens | Kurt Rowells | Lakes Community |
| 2013 | Paul Hass | Glenbard West | AAA Womens | Kelly Hass | Glenbard West |
| 2013 | Jim Westphal | Hinsdale Central | AAA Mens | Jay Ivory | Lake Park |
| 2012 | Mark Truesdale | Rock Falls | A Womens | Damani Shakoor | Seton Academy |
| 2012 | Keith Forth | Richmond Burton | A Mens | Ed Adams | Chicago Leo |
| 2012 | Chris Muth | Yorkville | AA Womens | Marcia Eberhard | Walther Lutheran |
| 2012 | Andy Andelmann | Jones College Prep | AA Mens | Andy Preuss | Glenbard South |
| 2012 | Dan Iverson | Naperville North | AAA Womens | Fenton Gunter | Evanston |
| 2012 | Jason Crowe | Plainfield South | AAA Mens | Jay Ivory | Lake Park |
| 2011 | Steve Wolf | Westmont | A Womens | Scott McMullen | Byron |
| 2011 | Brett Willhoit | Harvard | A Mens | Ed Adams | Chicago Leo |
| 2011 | Chris Muth | Yorkville | AA Womens | Derrick Calhoun | Morgan Park |
| 2011 | Troy Yunk | Belvidere North | AA Mens | Andy Preuss | Glenbard South |
| 2011 | John Burnside | New Trier | AAA Womens | Daniel R. Anderson | Hoffman Estates |
| 2011 | Chris Quick | Palatine | AAA Mens | Jay Ivory | Lake Park |
| 2010 | Steve Wolf | Westmont | A Womens | Scott McMullen | Byron |
| 2010 | Pam Deery & Henry Nykaza | Beecher | A Mens | Joe Erb | Winnebago |
| 2010 | Chris Muth | Yorkville | AA Womens | Benny Phillips | Kankakee |
| 2010 | Troy Yunk | Belvidere North | AA Mens | Ron Towner | Hillcrest |
| 2010 | Jon Macnider | Schaumburg | AAA Womens | Pat Richards | Hinsdale Central |
| 2010 | JB Hanson | Lake Zurich | AAA Mens | Jay Ivory | Lake Park |
| 2009 | Joe and Janet Erb | Winnebago | A Womens | Todd Volkert | Sherrard |
| 2009 | Valerie Gassman | Sterling Newman Catholic | A Mens | Jim Spratt | Oregon |
| 2009 | Chris Muth | Yorkville | AA Womens | Michelle Lillis | Rock Island |
| 2009 | Troy Yunk | Belvidere North | AA Mens | Ron Towner | Hillcrest |
| 2009 | Joe Parks | Palatine | AAA Womens | Steve Currins | Palatine |
| 2009 | Paul Vandersteen | Neuqua Valley | AAA Mens | Stan Reddel | York |
| 2008 | Joe and Janet Erb | Winnebago | A Womens | Scott McMullen | Byron |
| 2008 | Steve Wolf | Westmont | A Mens | Scott Ward | Reed-Custer |
| 2008 | Shannon Schroeder | Crystal Lake Central | AA Womens | Jody Gitelis | Barrington |
| 2008 | Evan Thorpe | Dixon | AA Mens | Stan Reddel | York |
| 2008 | Bob Thomson | Geneva | AAA Womens | | |
| 2008 | Dave Racey | Naperville North | AAA Mens | | |
| 2007 | Joe and Janet Erb | Winnebago | A Womens | Todd Volkert | Sherrard |
| 2007 | Joe and Janet Erb | Winnebago | A Mens | Brad Cirks | Orion |
| 2007 | Shannon Schroeder | Crystal Lake Central | AA Womens | Jody Gitelis | Barrington |
| 2007 | Michael Lambdin | Sycamore | AA Mens | Art Pahl | Bolingbrook |
| 2007 | Bob Thomson | Geneva | AAA Womens | | |
| 2007 | Paul Vandersteen | Neuqua Valley | AAA Mens | | |
| 2006 | Joe and Janet Erb | Winnebago | A Womens | Jeff Schutt | Aurora Christian |
| 2006 | Steve Wolf | Westmont | A Mens | Bill Koehne | Walther Lutheran |
| 2006 | Mark McCabe | Hinsdale Central | AA Womens | Fenton Gunter | Evanston |
| 2006 | Joe Parks | St. Charles North | AA Mens | Michael Kennedy | Neuqua Valley |
